Meta’s Metaverse Is ‘Outdated Concept’ That is ‘By no means Labored,’ Tech CEO Says

  • Phil Libin is the previous boss of Evernote and is now CEO of videoconference firm Mmhmm.
  • He informed Insider he’d tried out Horizon Workrooms, Meta’s VR assembly software program, and wasn’t impressed.
  • He described Meta’s imaginative and prescient of the metaverse as “uncreative.”

When tech founder Phil Libin donned his Oculus VR headset to check out Meta’s first metaverse product, he hoped it would not be horrible.

“I had a really, very robust feeling that it might suck, however I went into it with as a lot hope as doable that I’d be pleasantly stunned,” Libin mentioned in an interview with Insider.

He and his workers at videoconference firm Mmhmm, the place he’s CEO, had been attempting out Meta’s Horizon Workrooms product. Horizon Workrooms lets folks use VR headsets for digital work conferences within the so-called metaverse.

Libin mentioned his intestine intuition turned out to be appropriate. “It was solely tolerable for a couple of minutes,” he mentioned.

He believes that utilizing VR for conferences is much less attractive than acquainted applied sciences comparable to


, the place folks can nonetheless do real-world issues like consuming a cup of espresso. “Cannot do this with an enormous plastic factor on my face with out spilling sizzling espresso throughout myself,” Libin mentioned.

Facebook horizon workrooms model

Horizon Workrooms, Meta’s VR conferences product.


The phrase “metaverse” is borrowed from science-fiction and refers to a future model of the web accessed via immersive applied sciences comparable to virtual-reality and augmented-reality headsets. It has been pushed specifically by Mark Zuckerberg, who rebranded Fb as Meta in October.

In its fourth quarter earnings report Wednesday, Meta mentioned its new metaverse enterprise misplaced $10 billion and its person base shrank for the primary time in its historical past. Meta inventory plummeted 26.4% Thursday, erasing almost $240 billion from the corporate’s valuation within the largest one-day wipeout in US company historical past.

Libin has beforehand been crucial of the hype surrounding the metaverse. In a podcast interview final month, he in contrast the hype with communist propaganda he acquired as a baby residing within the former Soviet Union.

And he stays unconvinced.

He says the imaginative and prescient of the metaverse introduced by Meta – one in every of an “interconnected 3D world that we expertise for a lot of hours a day, each for enjoyable and for work primarily via VR” – “that bundle of issues is godawful.”

“It is an previous concept,” Libin informed Insider. “It is uncreative, it has been tried many, many occasions over the previous 4 a long time and it is by no means labored.”

Proponents of the metaverse consider we’ll have to attend to see its full potential, Libin mentioned, however he does not assume that is how nice know-how works.

“I feel nice know-how begins out being primitive, however it begins out being nice instantly,” he mentioned. Over time, he mentioned, nice know-how will get “extra polished and extra mature and extra refined.”

He gave the instance of early online game consoles, and his first ever buy from Amazon within the mid-nineties.

“It was my very first ever e-commerce transaction — went to the Amazon web site, and Amazon within the mid-nineties was tremendous primitive. It was like a text-based website all you would do is purchase books from it. And it did not have one-click checkout: it was very, very primary. However I purchased a few books and I bear in mind understanding at that time, ‘that is wonderful.'”

As for Horizon Workrooms, Libin mentioned: “It is not gonna get higher as a result of it began unhealthy. It began silly. It might get extra refined, however it’ll simply be extra refined – however nonetheless unhealthy.”

Related posts